Monday, December 28, 2015
My problem with Ferrante
Continuing reading Elena Ferrante's My Brilliant Friend, volume 1 of her Neapolitan Trilogy, and, oddly (or perhaps not so oddly) I find myself having the exact same thoughts I had several years ago when reading Ferrante's best-known novel, The Days of Abandonment (you can see my 2 posts on that novel to see what I mean): She gets the novel off to a good start, clearly establishing the two main characters, the narrator (Elena) and her best/brilliant friend, Lila, both intelligent but Lila much more intuitive, self-taught, bold; though both live in the same Naples working-class neighborhood, Elena has more parental support, as her parents somewhat grudgingly support her continued schooling (voluntary and costly beyond elementary school, amazingly) while Lila's family pulls her from school and insists that she work in the family shoe-repair business. OK, Ferrante sets that up very well in the first third of the novel, yet as I continue reading I find I'm stuck at the same point: she keeps adding incidents that show in various guises this same initial theme; although the characters mature - the first half of the novel covers roughly 10 years of their lives - their relationship doesn't change or evolve, it's just a more-mature version of the same thing, focused on boyfriends rather than on play w/ dolls for example. Ferrante is an easy writer to read and to like, but in this novel as in Abandonment I find she doesn't get past her initial premise; she makes a point and then makes it again and again - maybe OK for a short novel from for 3 volumes? We'll see.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Glad to read this as I was beginning to think it was an "emperor's new clothes" situation since it has been so wildly praised elsewhere. I not read the first volume but felt stongly that it did not go into any depth in characterization. Also as compared to a piece of music it did not seem to have any dynamics...just kept going at the same "speed and loudness" with no tonal changes even with big events. As you say she kept adding incidents that didn't forward our understanding of the many characters.
ReplyDelete