Welcome

A daily record of what I'm thinking about what I'm reading

To read about movies and TV shows I'm watching, visit my other blog: Elliot's Watching

Wednesday, March 7, 2012

The climactic event in The Member of the Wedding is ... elided.

One of the strangest aspects of Carson McCullers's "The Member of the Wedding" is that - there's no wedding. Or, more accurately, the wedding, the climactic event toward which the whole novella seems to be building, is elided: throughout the first two sections, about 80 percent of the novel I would guess, we focus on Frankie Addams, and the issue or problem that sets the story in motion is that her brother is getting married in 2 days and she wants to, and expects to, go off with brother and bride and travel the world with them, live with them: she's obviously a very lonely and odd young (12) girl, very needy, precocious in some ways and terribly immature in others. We never expect the brother - whom we barely see anywhere in this novel - to take her with him, and it's not clear whether she truly expects that or is just articulating a fantasy. In any case, we never "see" what happens: Frankie goes off to the wedding in a nearby town, and then, bang, the next scene she's riding home in a bus and crying. The main dramatic moment is not dramatized. That makes us think: maybe the novel isn't what it seems, maybe it's not about the wedding at all bu about Frankie and her coming of age: her encounter with a soldier who tries to pick her up - she's incredibly naive to go into a hotel room with him, and incredibly mature to bash him over the head - shockingly, this girl who rattles on about everything to strangers, never tells anyone about this episode as far as we can see. Frankie will seem to many like a precursor to Holden Caulfield - even though she doesn't narrate her own story, so much is told through dialogue that we have her voice in our heads as clear as any narrative voice - but like HC she has that mixture of cockiness, worldliness, toughness, set against neediness, vulnerability, and naivete. The last section of the novel give us a little glimpse into a somewhat later - a year? two? - in Frankie's life, and we can see that she will move on, make friends, albeit other misfits like herself, will suffer and grow from her suffering. It's a much tougher and more unflinching novel than I'd expected - I think the movie version, from what I can recall, made Frankie more cute and sweet - and a very powerful delineation, mostly through dialogue, or a character, but it does feel like a short story extended to gargantuan, without the development, action, and complex web of relationships that we generally expect in a novel.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.