Tuesday, April 5, 2011
One of the most ludicrous first chapters ever written
Started Yashar Kemal's "The Burn the Thistles" last night and have to say the first chapter was so ludicrous I thought maybe it was a put-on. Many books (including mine) start with a paragraph or a passage that establishes a mood or a setting or a theme that is important to understanding and appreciating the work as it unfolds but is not essential to the plot or the characters, a bit of an introductory note or an overture, but in Thistles we get an entire fairly long chapter that describes the landscape and topography of, apparently, a Turkish (Kurdish?) mountainous region, dozens and dozens of place names, not one familiar (to Western readers anyway - and maybe they're fictitious), not a single human character - it's like a Hardy novel gone crazy. I thought, I'll never finish this book, I'll never even start it - and that said it's all the more surprising that in the 2nd chapter Thistles becomes far more conventional and engaging, as we begin with one of the familiar novelistic tropes - a stranger comes to town - we see a man on a night journey through the wilderness described in chapter 1 and he's on his way to a small town, in disguise - and when he arrives we learn he is not a stranger but a returning prodigal, a legendary fighter who will stay hidden in his uncle's home, and we learn that he will in some way confront the evil landlord/tyrant who has taken over the life of the village, so we're set for a classic confrontation and we'll see how it develops over some 400 pages. A Turkish novel, from I think the 60s, another in the many (mostly) European works destined for obscurity but reissued by the NYRB press (and mostly, sadly, remaindered).
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.